Accessory Dwellings

A one-stop source about multigenerational homes, laneway houses, ADUs, granny flats, in-law units, accessory dwelling units…

Stradivarius violins and cigar box guitars (Making sense of ADU construction costs)

ViolinCigar Box

Talk with a few contractors or review case studies on this website, and you might understandably be perplexed by the huge range of construction costs.  Check out these cost ranges:

Detached ADUs:
$9,000-$300,000 (mean is $98,000)
$13 – $438 per square foot (mean is $151/sf)

Attached ADUs:
$3,500-$200,000 (mean is $52,000)
$6 – $308/sf (mean is $82)

Source: Martin Brown’s analysis of data from an Oregon DEQ survey of ADUs.

As a contractor and developer who has built new ADUs and converted existing structures into ADUs (through my company, Orange Splot LLC), I often get asked for ballpark ADU cost estimates. This post won’t offer the short, crisp answer folks are usually looking for.  But I hope it at least offers some perspective on the wide range of ADU costs and provides a path towards a realistic cost estimate.

Construction vs. Development budgets

The development budget includes all the costs required to design, permit, finance, and build an ADU. Construction is usually the largest expense in a development budget, but never the only one. Non-construction development costs include:

  • Design
  • Building permits and/or impact fees
  • Financing (ie. lender fees, interest payments…)
  • Other professionals based specific needs of your project (ie. surveyor, structural engineer, environmental assessment/clean-up, project manager…)

If you’re putting together an ADU project budget, make sure to research and quantify these costs too. They may be smaller than construction costs, but they’re no less real.

Interpreting cost data

Q: “How much did that ADU cost?”                        A: “$120,000”

If this is all the information you have, there’s no way to tell if $120,000 is the construction cost or the full development cost. General contractors are more likely to quote the construction cost, because that’s the size of their contract and they’re unlikely to know about other costs involved. An owner is more likely to quote the full development cost, since they have to write all the checks. Either number can be useful, but it’s important to know which one you’re getting. If it’s not clear, ask!

Why is the cost range for ADUs so dramatic, even on a square foot basis?

(1) ADUs can be created in multiple ways, including the following.  These are listed in rough order of increasing cost per square foot:

  • Converting an unpermitted internal apartment into an ADU, which may just mean getting a permit and performing minor code compliance work;
  • Converting the attic or basement of a primary dwelling into an ADU;
  • Converting an attached or detached garage into an ADU;
  • Creating an ADU by adding on to an existing home or garage;
  • Building a new house and an ADU (detached or attached) simultaneously;
  • Building a detached ADU on the lot of an existing home; or
  • Building a detached ADU over a new garage on the lot of an existing home.

Note: Not all of these options are available in all jurisdictions. Check local codes!

(2) ADUs are built to very different construction standards. Some are built like cigar box guitars, designed to provide serviceable housing within a tight budget.  They may be partially or completely DIY.  Others are built more like violins, by experts sparing no expense to create beautiful, custom little dream homes for someone (often the builder) to live out the rest of their days. A high end kitchen remodel can easily cost more than double the cost of an Ikea kitchen of the same size; the same holds true for ADUs.

(3) Due to their relatively small size and inevitable location right next to a primary dwelling where the owner often lives, it’s tempting for handy owners to self-perform some or all of the construction work. This can decrease out-of-pocket costs, which sometimes results in under-reporting of an ADU’s full construction cost. An owner might remember to track material purchases but not factor in their own labor associated with buying or installing them, not to mention the cost a contractor would have included for overhead & profit for that portion of the job.

Do ADUs typically cost more per square foot than full sized homes?

Yes, for several reasons:

  • The small size of ADUs reduces efficiency of scale for labor, coordination, and materials
  • ADUs usually contain proportionally more kitchen and bathroom space (expensive) and less bedroom and hallway space (inexpensive)
  • ADUs are more likely to be located in back yards, away from the street, which may have poorer access for excavating machinery or material deliveries
  • ADUs are more likely to be built in tight locations where careful protection of existing structures and landscaping is required

So how do you estimate construction costs?

Over the course of an ADU project, there will be a few rounds of cost estimates. These iterative pricing rounds help the owner make an informed decision at each stage of development on whether to proceed forward, adjust the design or scope to try and bring it within budget, or cut losses and drop the idea all-together.

Right at the beginning, it makes sense to try and get a very rough cost estimate with as little work or expense as possible.  Hopefully, results will be encouraging and you can shift from dreaming & scheming to designing & building your ADU.  But if they’re not, you will have avoided wasting your own time (and likely other peoples’ time) on a project that isn’t financially feasible.

Since there’s no universal answer to the cost question, here are some steps to get over that initial cost estimating hump:

Step 1: Regulations and existing conditions

Read what your local zoning code has to say about ADUs (usually just 1-3 pages), along with any on-line pamphlet your jurisdiction may offer to help understand the rules. Zoning codes aren’t the most exciting things to read, but they’re really important because they answer questions with potentially large impacts on cost and basic feasibility, such as: Would an additional parking space be required? Does your jurisdiction allow the type (ie. internal or detached) ADU you’re hoping to build? Is there enough ceiling height in the basement or attic to convert it to an ADU without making expensive modifications? Does the ADU need to match the exterior appearance of the primary dwelling? Does the city require a preliminary inspection and walk-through for a prospective ADU? If after a little studying it’s unclear how the code would apply to your particular situation, it’s probably worth a trip to the local planning department for clarification.

You don’t have to do this work all by yourself, although it’s usually not all that hard. Another approach is to contract with an architect or project manager familiar with local regulations to help assess basic project feasibility. That will cost some $ early on, but might help avoid expensive surprises down the line.

Also note existing conditions of the property that may have significant cost impacts.  Is there a steep slope that would require a big (expensive) retaining wall?  Is the concrete footing holding up that garage you want to convert into an ADU crumbling and in need of replacement?  Will it be easy or complicated/disruptive to tie in to existing water and sewer lines?

With these basic questions answered, you’ll be much less likely to spend a lot of time scoping out a project that can’t be built – or missing a significant cost (ie. creating a new parking space, if required), that could blow an otherwise feasible project budget.

Step 2: Scope and Finish

Sketch out your vision for the ADU.

  • What form of ADU will it be (ie. conversion, addition, new construction…)?
  • How many square feet?  1 story or 2?  Any parts of design/construction you’d do yourself?
  • What types of systems and finishes are you envisioning (ie. flooring, cabinetry, windows, doors/trim, roofing, siding, appliances, countertops, HVAC system, water heating approach, green building measures…)?  Even if you don’t know what any of these cost, this information can help you, a contractor, or an architect sort through past projects to find ones most similar in finish level to what you’re planning.

Step 3: Preliminary Cost Estimate

Now you’re ready to start working on a rough cost estimate.  The key is to track down cost data from comparable projects as similar as possible to the one you’re scheming using some combination of the following techniques:

  • Use your network to find and interview owners, builders, and/or architects who have done ADUs or other small homes in your area somewhat like the one you’re contemplating.  Contact those involved and get whatever cost information they’re willing to share.  There probably won’t be great matches, but if you find something close you can start with a square foot cost comparison and make adjustments for differences between the homes (ie. add an inflation factor if the house was built a couple years ago; subtract some cost if the ADU contained a fancy heating system you wouldn’t be using…).
  • Review ADU case studies on this website for ones closest to the ADU you’re envisioning.  Scroll to the bottom of this post for a table summarizing costs per square foot from recent case studies.  Read ADU narratives for clues to finish levels and any cost adjustments you may need to make (ie. construction partly self-performed by the owner, demolition or other costs that might not apply to your project…).  Recognize that construction and development costs can differ widely based on location, so don’t expect an ADU cost in Portland to be indicative of what a similar one would cost in Detroit, MI (less) or Boston, MA (more).
  • Meet with general contractors and architects you might like to work with on your ADU project.  Share your ADU vision and ask them for cost estimates based on their experience.  If they take time to help with this and seem like they’d be good to work with, it’s nice to give them a chance to bid on the job if/when you get to that stage.

Beyond the initial estimate

With a rough idea for how much a proposed ADU will cost, it’s time to get serious about how to pay for it and to make a “Go”/”No Go” decision on whether to proceed.  If it’s a “Go” you can bring on a designer and/or general contractor to start fleshing out the ADU design and scope.  With the project becoming more real, participants in the process should be more willing to invest the time and effort it takes to prepare increasingly accurate cost estimates.  And these interim estimates can be critical in preventing cigar box guitars from morphing unexpectedly into Stradivarius violins that never get built.

We’ll wrap up this post with a quick summary of costs for ADUs profiled on this website.  If you find one similar to what you’re planning, that could provide a very rough initial estimate.

Good luck with the project!

Name Square footage Type Year built Development Cost Dev Cost / SF Notes:
Stephanie & Sam Dyer’s ADU 342 Detached new construction 2012 110,000 322
Joe Wachunas & Naomi Cole’s ADU: Reworking the garage 375 Garage conversion 2012 45,000 120 Costs exclude owner sweat equity
Derin & Andra William’s ADU: An Energy-Efficient Basement Apartment 650 Basement conversion 2012 60,000 92 Costs exclude owner sweat equity
Lesa Dixon-Gray’s ADU: Putting Mom in a Home, Sweet Home 590 Detached new construction 2011 110,000 186
Carolyn Matthews & Bruce Nelson’s Granny’s Garden Cottage 640 Detached new construction 2006 260,000 406
John Baker’s ADU: Renting the Basement for 37 Years 800 Basement conversion 1985 30,000 38 Significant sweat equity over 7 year renovation period
Martha Metzger’s ADU: Rent Now, Move in Someday 642 Detached new construction 2011 200,000 312
Michael Klepinger’s ADU: Ellen Basset’s Garden Cottage 660 Detached new construction 2012 125,000 189
Jeff McCaffrey & Beth Bonness’s ADU Hawthorne Guesthouse 700 Addition above new detached garage 2007 250,000 357
Wally & Lara Jones’ ADU: Keeping Good Neighbors 800 Basement conversion 2012 85,000 106 Costs exclude owner sweat equity
Lissa & Matt’s ADU: Planning for Our Son’s Future 375 Addition above new detached garage 2011 30,000 80 Incremental cost beyond base garage cost
Stephen William’s ADU: An ADU on the Alley 673 Detached new construction 2012 125,000 186
Susan Moray’s ADU: Updating History in Ladd’s 550 Detached garage conversion 2013 90,000 164
Scott Powers’ ADU: 3 Generations at Home 800 Detached new construction 2011 150,000 188

 

About these ads

About Eli Spevak

Community housing developer

4 comments on “Stradivarius violins and cigar box guitars (Making sense of ADU construction costs)

  1. Sue Thering
    May 7, 2014

    This is brilliant! But I can’t get the link to work! Sue

  2. Phil Hodsdon
    June 1, 2014

    Hi, I am just bought a home in Santa Cruz and I am going to build an ADU. Do you have a good firm/person/architect that I can work with?

    phodsdon@aol.com – Phil

    • Martin John Brown
      June 1, 2014

      Sorry, Phil, right now this site doesn’t have the resources to vet professionals. Perhaps someone else will see your query and chime in, though. We have been thinking about creating a way for professionals to list themselves, but it’s not ready for prime time yet. Stay tuned!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

BUTTON
%d bloggers like this: